Doctor Who – The Seeds of Doom Review (or ‘The Sleeper Hit of Doctor Who’)

“Well Gorilla, I went on record; I said this could be the sleeper match-up right here” – Jesse Ventura on the match between Mr Perfect and The Blue Blazer at Wrestlemania V.

The idea of a ‘sleeper hit’ – that being something that unexpectedly ends up being considered great despite a lack of promotion or general attention – is an interesting one.

I read a thread in the off-topic section of a Scottish Football forum the other day where a poster asked the question ‘What old Doctor Who stories should I track down on DVD?‘, and he was given the usual suspects in what is traditionally the Doctor Who hit parade. You know the ones…

  • Genesis of the Daleks
  • Caves of Androzani
  • Pyramids of Mars
  • Seeds of Death
  • Robots of Death
  • Talons of Weng Chiang
  • Earthshock
  • The Five Doctors
  • The Daemons
  • Ark in Space

…and so on and so forth.

Nobody ever talks about the Seeds of Doom.

It never seems to get brought up when people talk about classic stories or great guest stars, it was released in the tail end of the VHS release era and took an age to come out on DVD.

Things get gritty, with the Doctor resorting to snapping necks and loving it

It seems to be a hidden gem in the Doctor Who crown jewels, because despite the fact nobody really talks about it, that infamous old list – The DWM Mighty 200 – lists it as the 16th best Dr Who story of all time, and the 8th best of the Classic Era of the show.

Now I know I criticise those rankings – and quite rightly, when you consider the story next highest on the list is the overrated Terror of the Zygons – but the fact is that in spite of it getting no attention, the Seeds of Doom still ranks higher than many stories that people do talk about. So away from any sort of influencing of what is supposed to be ‘classic’, this story manages to break through.

Let’s review it and find out why that is.

Doctor Who – The Seeds of Doom Review: What’s This One About?

A story in two linked parts, this is about two seed pods found buried in the Antarctic. They are Krynoid pods – an alien form of hostile plant life that can eat animal tissue and take over an entire planet.

The first two episodes are like The Thing, with a small group of people in the South Pole being terrorised by one of their own who has been turned into a Krynoid.

The latter four take place back in England, with a flora-obsessed insane millionaire – having hired goons to steal the other pod – trying to harness the power of the Krynoid for his own gains.

Thoughts – Unlike Anything We’ve Seen Before

In so many ways, the Seeds of Doom is unlike anything we’ve seen up to this point in Doctor Who.

For a start, it’s far more adult than other stories.

Yes, we’ve seen death in almost every story in the show’s history up till now, but there’s a certain detachment to it. You can have a Dalek kill someone with its death ray or an Auton shooting someone with its detachable gun hand and I think that seems more clean and fantasy like.

The make-up here is exceptional. You can believe he’s turning into a plant.

Here you’ve got a man being clubbed over the head with a metal wrench, and then fed into a pulveriser. Fuck…that’s grim. That’s up there with getting dunked face first into burning chip fat.

On a similar note, censors might look at men dressed up in funny costumes like Cybermen or Sea Devils and think ‘That’s ok if they terrorise the Doctor; it’s not real’, and the kids would probably know that too. They can allow themselves to be scared by the usual Doctor Who monsters because they know it couldn’t happen to them.

But for the most part, the main antagonist is a gun-toting mercenary who regularly beats up the Doctor.

And then there’s the Doctor himself. We’ve seen him being physically involved with people before – Jon Pertwee’s Doctor especially. But Pertwee used a sort of made up martial art. Here, the Doctor is jumping on people from above & punching them in the face, as well as trying to snap people’s necks with his bare hands.

But it’s not just what he does from a physical point of view either – he acts more intense than normal. His jokes are laced with a notion that he’s taking things more seriously than usual, he’s angrily screaming at people, and he’s issuing orders to thugs to create Molotov cocktails.

So the Seeds of Doom is going down a thematic line that we’ve not seen before.

But it’s also stylistically different.

Here, the Doctor is seen as a sort of ‘Troubleshooter for Hire’, in that I suppose we’re to believe he’s just been living in England before he and Sarah are asked to go to the South Pole. And though it has UNIT in it, they are merely ‘soldier candy’ for the end part.

I don’t think it would have worked as a ‘traditional’ UNIT story, and had it involved the Brigadier and Benton it wouldn’t have come across half as intense as it does.

But I have to say, all these aspects that are different are fantastically good. We’re soon going to get to a point in Doctor Who where his link with ‘modern Earth’ is severed completely. Yes, stories with the ‘UNIT Family’ had ran their course in my opinion, but this

Similarly, I think this is a very good special effect for the time

format could have worked in at least a semi regular state.

So it’s a pity that it’s the only story of its kind, but it also makes it stand out more for me, because I think it’s brilliant.

Performance and Story Together

When I look back at some of my reviews, the ones that really stand out tend to be the ones where the actors put in brilliant performances, rather than it being an amazing story. You’ve only got to look at the Brain or Morbius review I recently published. Praising the story came secondary to praising some of the dialogue or the way the actors played it.

The Seeds of Doom has that of course, with top quality lines like “I’m not a patient man Doctor”, “Well your candour does you credit” to name but one exchange of many, and it has excellent performances throughout the cast, with no letdowns from anywhere.

But added to that is that this is one hell of a story. Where some adventures will spend an episode or two treading water, The Seeds of Doom moves at pace from beginning to end. The split of environment and restart with a new Krynoid in Episode 3 helps matters, there’s no doubt, but that’s not a crutch – it’s just good storytelling.

As I see it, looking at the Tom Baker era so far, you’ve got stories like Ark in Space which has a great plot and some efficient acting, then you’ve got stories like Brain of Morbius which have great acting and wonderful dialogue but a plot which is merely good, and you’ve got a story like the Pyramids of Mars which has both a very good script and very good performances but maybe doesn’t have the humour or the sparkling dialogue, and it slows down towards the end.

But the Seeds of Doom manages to have excellent performances combined with a powerful plot and quality dialogue.

But this is just shit. Rather than the Doctor picking something up from beneath the snow, he is clearly just ruffling through a box with Styrofoam in it.

I said that Brain of Morbius was my favourite story of the Baker era, but only one story hence, its lost it’s title to this.

John Challis – Living in the Shadow of Boycie

There’s a thread on a Doctor Who forum about the top 10 guest artists to appear in the show. And many of the names you’d expect to be on that list are on. The likes of Philip Madoc, Kevin Stoney, Peter Jeffrey, Julian Glover, Bernard Kaye, Peter Barkworth – they’re all there.

And they deserve to be of course. These people are excellent actors who do a wonderful job with what they are given.

But missing from that list is John Challis.

In the same way as people will criticise Ken Dodd’s performance in Delta and the Bannermen because it’s Ken Dodd and not because it’s poor (and when I eventually get to that review I’ll say that I think it’s actually a very well performed cameo role), I think people don’t want to put their name to praising Challis because he is famous for being Boycie in Only Fools and Horses.

You ask 100 British people where they know Challis from, and 100 will say Only Fools. That’s the role he’s most famous for, that’s the role he made a career on, but that’s a role that isn’t exactly critically acclaimed.

And yet, before he was Boycie he was Scorby. And he was magnificent.

In all of Doctor Who, there is not a better ‘hired goon’ character. He’s got him down to a tee. So many actors would take a reasonably well written character like that and do an efficient job of it, but it wouldn’t be memorable. But Challis does a fantastic job. He works so well against both Baker and Sladen, he’s fully invested in the character and he makes him multi-layered. You feel that there’s a certain vulnerability about him, and despite not having the flashy lines

There’s John Challis – or to most of you ‘Boycie from Only Fools & Horses’ – putting in a fine performance as Scorby

like Philip Madoc did as Solon, or the ridiculous OTT brilliance of Christopher Robbie’s Cyber Leader, he commands the screen when he’s on it.

So here’s to John Challis. I disassociate him with the Boycie character and commend him for being a quality actor in his own right, and would happily place him in my Top 10 Guest Artists in the show. Although, we’ll see how that goes once I’ve watched every story…

The Doctor and Sarah – Equals

Another aspect of this story that stands out is that the Doctor and Sarah are written very much as equals. He leans on her as much as she leans on him.

Gone is the dynamic of the older man and his young dumb sidekick here.

Of course, in modern Who this is par for the course. Towards the end of her run, Rose was very much equal billing with the Doctor, while now Matt Smith’s Doctor is positioned in equal footing to Amy (but not poor old Rory of course).

But it’s something new for this era, and since she’s only got two more appearances before she leaves, it’ll never happen again, which is sad.

Random Observations

  • While John Challis stands out as the best of the guest cast, it’s very strong on the whole with nobody letting the side down. I must commend the writing and casting of Harrison Chase as well as the performance of Tony Beckley in playing the role. You can fully invest in his creepy obsession with plant life, along with him being both dangerous and whimpering. Another massive plus point in the story.
  • On the other hand, if I have to criticise it, I’ll say that some of the attempts at making it look as though they were in Antarctic were pretty pathetic.
  • And that TARDIS prop is literally falling apart by this point.
  • Another slight criticism I have is that Scorby didn’t have to die. Although it fit in well with him having a breakdown, he seemed too savvy a character to go out to his death.
  • Oh, and while the principle of it was good, the execution of the cliffhanger to episode 4 was feeble.
  • Having said that, all the other cliffhangers were tremendous.
  • Incidental music and location is somewhat secondary to the other positives of this story, but they certainly help in making the story what it is.
  • The Krynoid in human state is of course just a repainted Axon, but it looks effective. And the makeup given to the likes of Keeler when he was half was transformed was also exceptional.

    The TARDIS has clearly seen better days

  • I could be wrong, but I believe the Krynoid on the house was done by stop motion animation. Again, it looks great – considerably better than the Scaracen in Terror of the Zygons – so you invest in it more.
  • I could question why the Doctor didn’t just take the TARDIS to the Antarctic, but hey-ho.
  • What I would say though is that having the Doctor not bother to wear any warm clothing at the South Pole makes him seem alien. A little thing, but again effective.
  • Another great line of dialogue worthy of mention: “It’ll be the end of everything! Everything! Even your pension”. Superb!
  • Tony Beckley appears to have noticeably shorter hair when filming on location.
  • Finally, how obvious is it that the Ecology Bureau is just Television Centre?

Doctor Who – The Seeds of Doom Review: Final Thoughts

As I said before, Brain of Morbius couldn’t even retain its title as the best Tom Baker story so far against its first challenger.

The Seeds of Doom is absolutely brilliant. Any issues with it – dealt with above in the Random Observations section – are trivial at best. No, this story – to me at least – is pretty much faultless. A wonderful example of Doctor Who and yet a departure from what we can usually expect from it.

It wouldn’t have worked with any other Doctor, nor would it have worked if Tom Baker approached the part with his usual level of frivolity. His seriousness, along with his interaction with the other characters, sells what is a super script.

I look at all the stories I’ve rated so far; I look at what came first for each of the first three Doctors and I look at this, and I’d honestly say this is probably the best yet. It’s just that good. In times to come there will be a couple more challengers to the crown in the classic era, like Weng Chiang and Androzani, and there are a few excellent stories in the modern era, but this deserves its place in the top 10 stories ever.

And going back to the very beginning of the review, nobody seems to talk about it or know about it.

It’s the very definition of the sleeper hit.


11 Responses to Doctor Who – The Seeds of Doom Review (or ‘The Sleeper Hit of Doctor Who’)

  1. Eugene says:

    Agreed – this story is pretty much perfect. John Challis never gets the recognition he deserves, and the chaps who play the two civil servants are great as well. My only gripe is that Tom goes WAY over the top in the cottage scenes where he shouts at Scorby. But what’s five seconds amidst six episodes of greatness?

  2. Zaphod says:

    Superb review. I agree with everything you have written about this story. It is superb. Powerful stuff really.

  3. col says:

    Just thought i would add Scorby And Reegan from The Ambassadors of Death would of made a great double act probably would of doubled crossed each other though of course



  5. Stuart, I think you just got dissed by a Dalek.

  6. Bill says:

    This is definitely one of my favorite serials. Chase is a far more interesting and menacing villain to me than a Dalek anyday. And I’m glad I’m not the only person who wished Scorby had lived.

  7. Bill says:

    Another random thought. And my apologies if double-posting annoys you, heh. But I just remembered another reason I like this serial and Chase in particular; he’s a very pragmatic and sensible villain (at least until he inevitably goes completely nutso towards the end – “All plant-eaters must die!” indeed!).

    When he promises Dunbar a ton of money in return for being his spy, storytelling conventions dictate that once Dunbar isn’t useful to him anymore, Chase ought to have him killed. Instead, he keeps his promise and even continues to employ Dunbar for inside info. Chase strikes me as a man who realizes that if he doesn’t keep his promises, he won’t be able to get anyone to do what he wants.

    Likewise, when Amelia turns up demanding her payment for the painting, Chase pays her, too, instead of killing her. Admittedly, it’s the equally pragmatic Scorby who suggests paying Amelia, but I suspect Chase might’ve eventually come to that decision on his own, given his treatment of Dunbar (leaving one to wonder why he stiffed Amelia to begin with). And he’s even intelligent enough to double what he owes her to (as far as he knows) get rid of her that much quicker.

    It’s little character details like that which make Chase and Scorby believable, realistic bad guys.

  8. Simon Clarke says:

    Yes.. this is one of my top 10 favourites.. even if all the pot plant shaking gets a bit much at times. It is the body horror of alien consuming human that was frightening when I watched it as a child(Ark In Space is the same). Plus that compost machine…and the climatic fight scene in it… horrifying screaming from the loser of the fight as they are consumed…. (and pumped into the garden to become compost!)

    Only criticism, is I think.. is at the end the Doctor forgets to reset the TARDIS co-ordinates from the Antarctica.. and so return there at the end of the story. But they never went there by TARDIS in the first place, but rather by helicopter.

    I think this story isn’t praised as much, as the Krynoid has very limited chance of a being repeat monster.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: