Stuart’s Top 30 Sitcoms of All Time: Part 4 (#15 – #11)

I’m beginning to regret the low placing of The US Office on my list even further now, having battered through the whole of Season 7 in short order and laughed at every single episode.

Oh well…

Anyway, back to the list.

#15 Red Dwarf

This is a bit of a nostalgia pick, considering some of it doesn’t really hold up so well now, but as a child of the 80s and 90s who was into science fiction, there was a time when Red Dwarf was pretty much the only show from the genre being red-dwarfproduced in the UK. As a result, I would watch the videos of it again and again.

Red Dwarf was at its best in Season 2, a season where pretty much every episode was brilliant. Fast forward to Season 8 and the show had lost its way completely.

24 years after Red Dwarf first hit the screens though, the show came back for another full season on Dave. With limited resources, Doug Naylor had to go back to basics, with a small cast stuck on a mining ship in deep space. I have to say that despite mixed reviews, I enjoyed it and I look forward to seeing more in the future.

Best Episode: Thanks For The Memory

A solid, well executed idea, good acting and a quality script, as the crew of Red Dwarf wake up to find they’ve lost their memory from the past few days, only to discover that they had done it intentionally

#14 Still Game

Any reader from outside Scotland might struggle to understand Still Game, and if you’re not from within the British Isles there’s a chance you haven’t heard of it.Stillgame

But the sitcom about two old men and their pals in a Glasgow scheme is excellent.

While the plots are never particularly ground breaking, the humour derives – for me at least – from the dialogue within them.

The relationships between the characters are the key, and – shallow as it may be – watching a sitcom where the characters use the same sort of swear words that most Scots use is just…well…funny.

What also works in Still Game’s favour is the consistency of it. There were six seasons and four specials and there wasn’t a bad episode among them.

Best Episode: Faimly

I’ll admit I haven’t seen some of the episodes in a while, but one that sticks out is the second episode of Season 1, with the storylines of Victor waiting for his family to visit him while they are back in the UK and Winston feuding with a fat thumper of a woman over gigot chops.

#13 Whatever Happened To The Likely Lads

Well obviously this is a hands down winner when it comes to best sitcom theme tune, that goes without saying.Likely Lads

But what I found interesting was that when I asked people on Twitter and Facebook what their top three sitcoms were, Whatever Happened To The Likely Lads got the most votes.

It’s amazing when you think that a show that until last month had not been repeated on British TV for god knows how long was enduring enough to attract so much love.

Here’s a show that differs from almost every other one on the list in that it’s one long narrative. Every episode  follows directly into the next one, and that includes the gap between Seasons 1 and 2.

Another thing about it – and it’s something that I don’t think many comedy writers or actors can manage now – is that it’s very heavily based upon conversation between the two lead characters. There’s very little in the way of slapstick or visual humour and yet it works so well.

The show tailed off a little towards the end, but it’s mostly very consistent.

Best Episode: One For The Road

The episode where Bob is arrested for drink driving while Terry is also locked up for football hooliganism (read that back and you wouldn’t think it was a sitcom) is a terrific example of the show with a brilliant punchline.

#12 The Inbetweeners

While shows like Skins showed a side to growing up that simply didn’t happen to anyone in reality, The Inbetweeners presented a more realistic and superbly funny side to the life of a teenager.Inbetweeners

Four distinct characters who any viewer could identify from his or her time at school, it figures so high because every episode is top notch.

The movie version wasn’t as funny as the TV show, but the news of a sequel in the making is still very welcome for me.

Best Episode: The Field Trip

Simon and Will vie for the affections of a new girl, Jay goes looking for a local woman who supposedly sleeps with school students whenever there’s a field trip down that next of the woods, Neil is lusted after by the Paedo Geography teacher and later in the episode punches a fish to death.


#11 The Simpsons

I’ve written about my feelings on the Simpsons before. You can check out an article I did at time of it’s 500th episode hereSimpsons

For me, despite there being now north of 500 episodes, the last good one I saw was the 197th one back in 1998. I’d stopped watching new episodes of the show altogether before the turn of the new millenium.

So they still make it, and it’s almost universally accepted that it’s pretty crap now, but you have to look at that episode number above. The last good one was #197, and up to that point it was mostly consistent and often times excellent. That’s good going for any show and well worthy of inclusion on this list.

If they’d stopped around the 200 mark it would have been a strong contender for the top 5.

Best Episode: Homer at the Bat

I’ve said that this is my favourite before, and I had plenty of people disagreeing with me.

Sure there are some other great ones like Cape Fear and Rosebud, but this is one episode I could watch every day and enjoy.

Proper use of celebrities (which is rare for the show), a fun plot and a great song to finish,

“We’re talking Hoooomer…Ossie and the Straw”

Get Involved In The Debate

Stuart Reviews Stuff is a free entertainment blog. If you enjoyed this or any other article on the site, please consider taking a moment to Like the official Facebook page. You can do that by clicking like on the side panel, or visiting the site here

You can also follow me on twitter @sgmilne

Feel free to get involved in the debate.



2 Responses to Stuart’s Top 30 Sitcoms of All Time: Part 4 (#15 – #11)

  1. Eugene says:

    Still Game is excellent – and I’m one of your English cousins. Good characters make for good comedy. Tam is a particular favourite of mine.

  2. […] Stuart’s Top 30 Sitcoms of All Time: Part 4 (#15 – #11) – The show checks in at #11 here, with Zombie Simpsons being an explicit penalty: […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: